Draw relations

Claim: a relation, a set, a quantity or a process is shown as a figure placed with the words that explain it, not as words alone.

What it asks

  • A relation between things is a graph; a set or a partition is regions; a quantity is length or position; a process is frames the reader steps through.
  • A table when the reader looks up symbols; a graph when the reader compares shapes or trends (Vessey 1991).
  • Position and length before angle, area or colour, which are judged less accurately (Cleveland 1984).
  • No decorative pictures: interesting but irrelevant material lowers learning, g = -0.33, with strongly varying results (Sundararajan 2020, a meta-analysis); decorative pictures are one kind of it.

Why

A diagram puts related items next to each other, so the reader neither searches nor infers what the page could show (Larkin & Simon 1987). Words with pictures beat words alone across the multimedia literature (Mayer 2020). Building a concept map gave g = 0.82 over activities without one, and studying a map gave 0.37 over them (Nesbit 2006); in the North American studies alone, building gave 0.47.

Limits

Animation beats static pictures only modestly, d = 0.37 overall and more for procedural-motor content (Höffler 2007); it helps when the change itself is what is learned (Ploetzner 2020). Translating between two representations is itself hard and needs support (Ainsworth 2006).